Making Peace With Certain Affiliate Realities
(This is a bit of a downer of a post, so I’ll pre-apologize and get that out of the way. But it’s something that needs to be talked about at some point. So, umm, yeah. Sorry.)
As discussed here at various points, affiliate marketing can take many, many forms, which is one of the things that interests me most about it. You can create a site about just about anything and, to greater or lesser extents, make some money. Not only can you write about a virtually endless number of things, but you can tackle it from any number of angles, creating mini-sites, building huge, honking sites, engaging surfers directly, pretending surfers aren’t there, and so on.
In the end, though, your goal as an affiliate is to make money. If you simply wanted to create websites and thought money was of the Devil, you could do that and choose to never include affiliate links. So, by definition, if you’re including affiliate links on your sites, your goal is to make money.
In some cases your desire for money meshes perfectly with your audience. Let’s say you geek out over digital cameras and start a site that reviews digital cameras you’ve had in the past. Someone searches on “digital camera reviews”, lands on your site, and they buy a digital camera using your links. They get great advice on the best camera for them, you get a fat commission, the online retailer sells a digital camera, and everyone is happy. Win-win.
But if you play the affiliate game long enough, you run out of no-brainers like that at a certain point. Or you build a different sort of site on a whim and find that it’s much more profitable than your digital camera site. Regardless of the reason, most affiliates arrive at a point where they find themselves building sites solely to make money, without necessarily adding any value to the experience of surfers who land on their site. The affiliate makes money from the surfer landing on their site, but the surfer doesn’t take much away from the exchange. It’s not really a win-lose situation, more a win-push situation.
The Cisco certification site I’m building is a good example of this. If you look at the content there (and are blunt and prone to speaking your mind), you can’t help but say something along the lines of: “If I’m looking for info on CCNA classes and land on your site after searching for “CCNA classes” in Google, that’s not really helpful. You’re just repeating basic stuff I already know, not telling me where I can take classes at, what they cost, or anything useful like that. Sure, you’ve got Google Adsense ads right there which link to actual programs offering classes, but that’s annoying for me to have click two extra times to get to some place that actually offers CCNA classes.”
And you’d be exactly right. On every point. Guilty as charged. I’m intentionally creating content that is solely designed to rank well in search results for terms that I know are profitable when Adsense ads are clicked. Even worse, if you look at all of the posts on the site so far, I’m basically just regurgitating the same basic, very broad information over and over. I’m optimizing each page for best traction in search results, making it unique enough, and using different combinations of commonly-associated semantic terms, but it’s basically the same damn stuff.
Even worse than all that, I’m intentionally making the Adsense links look like normal navigation links on the site, with the sole intention of hoping that less than savvy surfers won’t even realize those are ads and click on them, thinking they are navigational links to the sorts of things they wanted when they searched for “CCNA classes” in the first damn place and landed on my page. Again, guilty as charged.
Why, then, am I being an ass like that? Why am I cluttering up search results with pages that are designed to add no value to a surfer’s experience and only designed to trick them into clicking links that make me money. Because it works. Because I like money. Because I can.
If that sounds cold and heartless, well, it is cold and heartless. I’ve made the decision that I like money more than I like always being warm and fuzzy in everything I do. Sure, I could justify the above in all sorts of ways (I’m refining their search by getting them to a central page where multiple CCNA programs/boot camps are accessible via a single click; some less savvy users appreciate general, broad overviews; compared to outright spam and sites that scrape keywords and would otherwise appear in search results, my pages are actually useful and helpful) but in the end that’s a silly exercise and we all know it.
It’s important to note, though, that the last thing I’m suggesting is that it’s an all-or-nothing decision. I build lots of kinds of sites and will continue to do so. Some will be mercenary and heartless, designed to just make money and concerned with little else. Other sites I build, like this one, will be much more useful and more akin to the win-win situation outlined above in the digital camera scenario. I seem to work more efficiently when I’m mixing in a variety of types of sites, so that’s usually how I work.
Where you draw your own line in the sand is obviously up to you. My goal in bringing all of this up is to not only be open and honest about the realities of some of the things that go on in the affiliate world, as well as pointing out that the canvas you have to work with is very broad. You might stick solely to projects that you believe are useful and better the Web as a whole, and you can still make tons of money. Conversely, you might decide to be very mercenary and to only build sites that make you the most money, with no regard to anything else. As long as you sleep well at night, the sky’s the limit.
posted in Adsense, Getting Started | 0 Comments